Example 1: Testing fungicides against wood decay
Adapted from June 2017, Paper 1B · Question 11(b)
Question 1
The photograph shows the logs left behind after an area of forest has been cut down.
These logs are decomposed by fungi.
Some of the logs removed from the forest are used to make garden benches.
The photograph shows a garden bench.
The garden bench is painted with a fungicide solution.
This prevents the wood being decomposed because fungicide kills fungi.
There are different fungicides that can be used.
Design an investigation to find out which fungicide is best at preventing the decomposition of wooden logs.
Your answer should include experimental details and be written in full sentences.
Final answer
Cut equal-sized pieces from wood of the same species and age, and use several pieces for each fungicide. Apply a different fungicide to each group, using the same volume of solution, and expose all the pieces to the same type and amount of fungus. Keep the temperature and moisture the same for every group. Measure the mass of each piece before treatment and again after the same stated period, for example four weeks (at least one week). Compare the mean mass lost for each fungicide; the fungicide with the smallest mass loss is best at preventing decomposition.
Mark scheme points
- M1 Test different fungicides, using a separate group for each fungicide.
- M2 Use comparable wood, such as wood of the same species or age, or from the same tree.
- M3 Use more than one log or sample for each fungicide, or repeat the test.
- M4 Measure the wood’s mass before and after the test, or determine the change in mass.
- M5 State how long the test runs; the period should be at least one week.
- M6 Keep one listed condition the same, for example temperature, moisture, oxygen, volume of fungicide, or fungal exposure.
- M7 Keep a second listed condition the same. Any two of the listed conditions can earn the two standardisation points; the overall maximum is 6 marks.
Explanation
Testing different fungicides lets you compare them. Using similar wood and repeating the test makes the comparison more reliable. Keep other conditions the same so the fungicide is the main difference between groups. Measuring mass at the start and end shows how much wood has been lost during the stated period. Less mass lost means less decomposition, so the fungicide with the smallest mass loss works best.
Common mistakes
- Changing the wood type, moisture or temperature between groups makes it harder to tell whether the fungicide caused the difference.
- Giving only a final mass, or not stating the test duration, does not show the mass lost over a defined period.
- The best fungicide gives the smallest mass loss, not the largest.