Example 1: Charge transfer and aircraft refuelling
January 2020 · Paper 2P · Question 4(c)
Question 1
A student uses this apparatus to demonstrate the effect of electric charge.
He pours some fine powder into a funnel.
The fine powder moves through a length of plastic tubing and falls into a metal can.
The metal can rests on a metal cap.
The metal cap is connected to a thin piece of metal via a metal rod.
When the powder lands in the can, the thin piece of metal moves away from the metal rod.
The student suggests that this demonstration is similar to refuelling an aircraft.
The powder represents the fuel and the metal can represents the fuel tank in the aircraft.
Explain how the student should modify this apparatus to demonstrate how to minimise the dangers when refuelling an aircraft.
You may add to the diagram to help your answer.
Final answer
Connect the metal can, representing the fuel tank, to the ground with a wire. Charge can then flow to or from the ground, so it does not build up on the tank. This reduces the risk of a spark causing a fire or explosion.
Mark scheme points
Any three of these four points are needed for full marks:
- M1 Identify a relevant danger, such as a spark, fire or explosion.
- M2 Earth the metal can or aircraft; for example, connect it to the ground with a wire.
- M3 State that charge flows to or from the ground.
- M4 State that charge will not build up on the metal can or aircraft.
Explanation
Charge building up on the fuel tank could produce a spark. If the spark ignites fuel vapour, it could cause a fire or explosion. Connecting the metal can to the ground with a wire provides a path for charge to flow. Charge may flow either way, and this prevents it from building up on the can.
Common mistakes
- Candidates generally recalled the need for earthing and the hazards well. Remember that charge can flow either towards or away from the ground through the wire.
- Naming a spark or fire alone does not explain how the danger is reduced; include the earth connection and what it does to the charge.