Example 1: Using a Diagram
Question 1
(Source: © edwardolive/Shutterstock)
The patella is a small, irregularly shaped bone that is denser than water.
Describe how to find the mass and the volume of the patella bone.
Final answer
Use a zeroed balance on a flat surface to measure the mass of the dry patella.
Put a known volume of water in a measuring cylinder and record the initial volume. Completely submerge the patella without splashing and record the final volume. The volume of the patella is:
volume of patella = final volume − initial volume
Read the measuring cylinder at eye level and ensure that no water is lost.
Mark scheme points
- M1 Use a balance to measure mass and a measuring cylinder to measure volume.
- M2 Use water displacement to determine the volume of the irregular bone.
- M3 Record the initial and final water volumes and calculate their difference.
- M4 Include a valid accuracy detail, such as reading the measuring cylinder at eye level, avoiding splashing, or ensuring the bone is totally submerged.
Explanation
A balance directly measures the mass. A ruler cannot be used to find the volume because the patella has an irregular shape.
The bone is denser than water, so it will sink and can be completely submerged. Submerging it raises the water level by an amount equal to the bone’s volume. Therefore, subtracting the initial reading from the final reading gives the volume.
- Mass: use a balance, preferably with the dry bone and the balance zeroed.
- Volume: use water displacement in a measuring cylinder.
- Accuracy: avoid splashing or trapped air and read the scale at eye level.
Common mistakes
- Do not just describe finding density; the question asks specifically how to measure mass and volume.
- Do not use a ruler for this irregularly shaped bone.
- Do not omit either the initial or final water reading, or the subtraction of the two readings.
- Do not leave the bone partly submerged or allow water to splash out.
- Examiners reported that many candidates chose displacement but lost marks by giving too little detail or omitting essential apparatus, especially the measuring cylinder and a valid accuracy detail.