Example 1: Applying the particle model of a gas
June 2020 (R) · Paper 1P · Question 13(b)
Question 1
This question is about pressure in gases.
Photograph 2 shows a boiled egg, without its shell, placed in the top of the conical flask containing hot air.
The flask is no longer being heated.
The egg seals the flask so that no air escapes.
Photograph 3 shows the egg and the flask a short time later.
Explain why the egg moves down into the flask and then stops moving.
Refer to ideas about pressure in your answer.
Final answer
The air in the flask cools, so its molecules move more slowly and the pressure inside the flask decreases. The greater pressure outside pushes the egg down into the flask. As the egg moves down, the volume of the trapped air decreases and its pressure rises. The egg stops when the pressure inside and outside balance, so there is no resultant force pushing it further down.
Mark scheme points
Any four of the following mark-bearing points are sufficient; together they should explain why the egg moves down and then stops.
- M1 The air in the flask cools.
- M2 The molecules slow down, or their kinetic energy decreases.
- M3 The pressure inside the flask decreases as its temperature decreases.
- M4 The pressure outside the flask is greater than the pressure inside.
- M5 The resultant force from the air pushes the egg down the neck of the flask.
- M6 As the egg moves down, the volume of air in the flask decreases.
- M7 The pressure inside the flask increases as the volume decreases.
- M8 Eventually, the pressure inside and outside the flask balance.
- M9 The resultant force is then zero, so the egg stops moving down.
Explanation
Cooling makes the gas molecules move more slowly. Their collisions with the flask walls produce a lower pressure inside the flask, so the greater pressure outside pushes the egg inward.
As the egg moves farther into the flask, it reduces the volume available to the trapped air, causing the internal pressure to rise. The egg stops when the inside and outside pressures balance and the resultant force on it becomes zero.
Common mistakes
- Saying only that the air cools, without explaining that the pressure inside the flask decreases.
- Reversing the pressure difference: it is the greater pressure outside that pushes the egg down.
- Explaining why the egg moves but not why it stops: include the pressure balance and zero resultant force.