Example 1: Using a Diagram
Question 1
Cat Y has thick, black fur.
Both cats have the same body temperature and transfer energy to their surroundings when they are outside on a cold day.
Refer to conduction, convection and radiation in your answer.
Final answer
Cat X loses more energy by conduction and convection than cat Y. Cat Y’s fur traps air. Air and fur are poor conductors, so conduction is reduced. The trapped air cannot move around, so convection is also reduced.
Cat Y loses more energy by radiation than cat X because its black fur is a better emitter and emits radiation faster than the light-coloured skin of cat X.
Mark scheme points
Any six of the following points earn the available marks:
- M1 Cat X loses more energy by conduction or convection than cat Y.
- M2 Cat Y loses more energy by radiation than cat X.
- M3 Cat Y’s fur traps air.
- M4 A larger surface area increases conduction losses.
- M5 Air is a poor conductor or a good insulator.
- M6 Fur is a poor conductor or a good insulator.
- M7 Trapped air cannot move around.
- M8 Trapped air reduces convection.
- M9 Black surfaces are better emitters or emit radiation faster.
Explanation
Start by comparing the two cats for each energy-transfer method:
- Conduction: cat Y has insulating fur and trapped air, both of which are poor conductors. Therefore, cat X loses more energy by conduction.
- Convection: the air trapped in cat Y’s fur cannot circulate freely, so convection is reduced. Therefore, cat X loses more energy by convection.
- Radiation: both cats have the same temperature, but cat Y has a black surface. Black surfaces are better emitters, so cat Y loses more energy by radiation.
Common mistakes
- Do not only state that fur traps air; explain that air is a poor conductor and reduces conduction.
- Do not say trapped air increases convection. It cannot move around freely, so convection is reduced.
- Do not reverse the radiation comparison: black surfaces emit radiation better than light-coloured surfaces.
- Do not discuss black surfaces being better absorbers, because the cats are transferring energy to their surroundings.
- Examiners reported that many candidates knew fur traps air, but fewer explained that air is a poor conductor or that trapped air reduces conductive losses.