Example 1: Using a Diagram
Question 1
Diagram 1 shows a planet orbiting a star, and a moon orbiting a planet.
Diagram 2 shows the region around the Sun, a yellow star, where liquid water can exist on the surface of planets. This is because the surface temperature of the planet is between 0°C and 100°C.
Explain what would happen to the position of the liquid water region if the Sun was replaced with a blue star of the same size.
Final answer
The blue star is hotter than the Sun, so the liquid water region would be further away from the star, with a larger radius.
Mark scheme points
- M1 The blue star is hotter than the Sun.
- M2 The liquid water region is further away from the star, or has a larger radius.
Explanation
A blue star has a higher surface temperature than a yellow star such as the Sun. Therefore, planets at the same distance would receive more heating and would be too hot for liquid water. The region where the surface temperature is between 0°C and 100°C must therefore be located further from the star.
Common mistakes
- State both that the blue star is hotter and that the region moves further away.
- Do not just say that the liquid water becomes a gas; the question asks about the position of the region.
- Do not place the region closer to the hotter star.
- Examiners reported that most candidates recognised that the blue star would be hotter, but only the most able candidates correctly linked this to the region moving further away.