Example 1: Explaining osmosis in red blood cells
Adapted from January 2022 (R), Paper 2B · Question 6(c)(ii)
Question 1
A teacher carries out a demonstration to show the effect of different concentrations of salt solution on red blood cells.
This is the teacher’s method.
- dilute a sample of blood using a salt solution that has the same concentration as blood plasma
- place 1cm3 of the diluted blood into each of three test tubes labelled A, B and C
- add 10cm3 of water to tube A
- add 10cm3 of 1% sodium chloride solution to tube B
- add 10cm3 of 5% sodium chloride solution to tube C
- leave each tube for 5 minutes
- compare the cloudiness of the solutions in the three test tubes
- take a drop of liquid from each tube and put on separate microscope slides
- observe each slide under a microscope
After 5 minutes, these are the teacher’s observations.
- tube A – a clear red solution
- tube B – a cloudy red suspension
- tube C – a cloudy red suspension
When the teacher looks down a microscope for cells on each slide, these are the teacher’s observations.
- slide from tube A – no cells are seen
- slide from tube B – normal biconcave red cells are seen
- slide from tube C – red cells are seen but the cells have shrunken edges
The photographs show the teacher’s observations.
Explain the differences between the teacher’s observations of the slides from each tube.
Final answer
In tube A, water enters the red blood cells by osmosis, causing them to swell and burst, so no cells are seen. In tube B, water moves into and out of the cells at equal rates, so there is no net movement and the cells remain normal. In tube C, water leaves the cells by osmosis, causing them to shrink.
Mark scheme points
- M1 Water enters the red blood cells in tube A.
- M2 Water leaves the red blood cells in tube C.
This is one valid full-mark route. The mark scheme awards 2 marks for any two of these references: water enters cells in A; water enters and leaves, or has no net movement, in B; water leaves cells in C; or osmosis.
Explanation
In A, the surrounding distilled water is more dilute than the contents of the red blood cells, so water enters through their partially permeable membranes by osmosis. The cells swell and burst, which explains why none are visible.
In C, the salt solution is more concentrated than the cell contents, so water leaves the cells by osmosis and they shrink. In B, water moves in both directions at equal rates, so the cells keep their normal shape.
Common mistakes
- The examiner report notes that many candidates correctly linked the missing cells in A to water entering by osmosis and bursting, and identified water leaving cells in C. Make sure your explanation connects the direction of water movement to the observed change.
- For B, avoid saying that water does not move at all: it moves in and out at equal rates, so there is no net movement.